PHOTOS: Natalie, Blake, And Michelle Work The Red Carpet

by Julia Rubin | 2:20 pm, January 12th, 2011

Last night, three of our favorite red carpet regulars — Natalie Portman, Blake Lively and Michelle Williams — once again faced the flashbulbs, which means they now have to face our ruthless fashion analysis. We’ve broken down their looks piece by piece in the slideshow below. Do you agree with our picks?

Enable JavaScript to check out our fancy slideshow.

1.Dresses

Natalie wore a black and tan floor-length Vena Cava dress with a keyhole neckline and red detailing, Blake went for purple embellished Marchesa and Michelle donned a black lacy Oscar de la Renta frock with a wide neck and satin bow.

WINNER: Natalie, who wins by default because the proportions of Michelle's dress are off and Blake's shoulder poofs bug us.

2.Shoes

Natalie chose black Aldo (!) heels, Blake rocked maroon patent Burberry t-straps and Michelle wore black satin Louboutin pumps.

WINNER: Blake, because those shoes are major.

3.Accessories

Natalie accessorized with a black Tiffany bangle and quilted Dior chain bag and Blake showed off Lorraine Schwartz turquoise baubles, while Michelle went minimal and just carried a simple black Ferragamo clutch.

WINNER: Blake. Unlike the other two, she actually had some fun with her jewelry.

4.Hair & Makeup

Natalie had a maternal glow to complement her wavy, glossy locks, Blake's hair was messy and her pink eye makeup stuck out and Michelle's neutral makeup accented her blonde cropped 'do.

WINNER: Michelle — flawless hair and makeup is sort of her thing.