1. Mediaite
  2. Gossip Cop
  3. Geekosystem
  4. Styleite
  5. SportsGrid
  6. The Mary Sue
  7. The Jane Dough
  8. The Braiser

Project Runway Finale, Part 1: Michael’s Epic Meltdown

The final four became the Fashion Week Three on part one of the Project Runway (three-hour, wow) finale.

No one was really the “winner” although it would be a shock if Mondo didn’t take the grand prize. Instead, the loser was Michael Costello, who was so traumatized it bordered on disturbing.

It was the time in the season for Tim Gunn to globe-trot and visit each designer at home. We met Andy first, who was hard at work on a Laos-based collection in Hawaii. Tim was impressed, but cautioned about the lack of actual designing that had taken place.

It was the opposite reaction to Michael in Palm Springs, CA. Michael told Tim his plan was to make “150 pieces,” which was a bright red flag. In Palm Springs we met Richard, Michael’s partner, and learned that on February 28, 2007, Richard outed Michael to his mom and dad — parents who wanted him to stay married. His family, said Richard, have not been supportive over these past four years, and have made an effort “since he got on the show.” Michael’s collection is based on the sky and feathers.

Tim goes and sees Mondo in Denver, who is piecing together a Day of the Dead meets vintage Mexican circus collection. If it sounds a bit crazy, it is. Tim describes one piece as “teen’s pajamas.” Mondo’s family is more accepting than Michael’s, and we meet his boyfriend Ben, who is strangely silent the entire time. Next Tim visits Gretchen in Portland, OR. Her relationship has failed, her back account is empty. We don’t get much more of a backstory, but these are not happy times for our favorite egotistical designer. Her look takes “rural cultures from around the world” and incorporates them with her Western theme.

On the runway, the judges seem only truly impressed with Mondo, while Andy puts a tiny bikini out there, which Heidi Klum calls a “throwaway piece.” But in the end he’s safe, and it is Michael who goes home. He squints his way through his obligatory Auf Wiedersehen, until he breaks down backstage. His jarring, viscerally reaction — sobbing in the corner — catches the other contestants off guard. He says his parents will abandon him, and will tell him to abandon his dreams. We’re going to need a reunion show to make sure Michael Costello is doing alright. Either way, it’s Fashion Week next, and final, week.

Quote of the Week: “He looks like Pocahontas meets Naomi Campbell.” – Michael describing Andy’s look.

Quote of the Week (that made me laugh): “It’s like design diarrhea. Stop designing.” Tim to Michael.

Quote of the Week (by Tim Gunn): “Mix them up in a bowl, and put them on a plate, you could have a really, truly hot mess.” – to Andy.

Insult of the Week: “My interest was not piqued. It feels a little crunchy-granola.” – Nina Garcia to Gretchen, after Gretchen says she wants to “pique your interest.”

Fashion Term I Had to Look Up: “Copper-colored eating clothes.” – Michael Kors to Michael. Looked it up. Still not sure.

Even I Knew This was a Bad Sign: In the workroom, Tim left the designers by telling Mondo, Gretchen and Andy to “carry on, and Michael — don’t choke.” Tim knew.



  • Graphics Gal

    They kicked off the wrong person…Gretchen’s clothing is horrid!

  • wuwei

    Clearly Michael is a FASHION GENIUS … incredibly talented & eminently productive. It is tragic he was so harshly critiqued + eliminated!! WHY??!! Not only have we endured gretchen’s dreadful negative ruthless critcism of the other more talentend designers, but we’ve had also had to hear her whine about her relationship / money problems. WHO CARES! Her clothing looks like really bad 1960-70′s copies: not “granola” just hippie re-treads: BORING! Mondo’s fashion is inspiring, while Andy’s is fresh & ambitious: their work merits serious attention as does MICHAEL’s… It is unbearable to suffer gretchen’s bitchiness, rudeness, incessant complaining, temper tantrums + her nightmare hippie rags, so regrettably I will no longer watch project runway. If the network chooses controversy over TALENT, perhaps more people will turn away. Good luck with everything Michael and please keep designing your wonderful fashions! YOU ARE FANTASTIC!!!

  • supersasha

    The judges fcuked up, yet again.
    If they continue with this kind of shenanigans, the show will soon be a flop.
    Heidi’s at fault here.
    I know Nina and Michael did not like Gretchen.
    But Heidi was Gretchen’s greatest champion.
    I think the German should be ousted ASAP.

  • Frances77

    I’m so mad – Michael’s collection was the one I really wanted to see! It looked so rich and he had lots of new ideas I’ve never seen before. He seems a bit inexperienced – it sounds like his creativity has been squashed by his family – but he has fashion genius just oozing out of him… I can’t wait to see what he does next – I hope this show opens up some doors for him because I think he’s just scratched the surface of his talent.

    BTW, I think Gretchen is a good designer, but her collection was not a runway collection.

  • Frances77

    Another BTW – Michael said “Copper-colored evening clothes”, not “Copper-colored eating clothes” :)

  • fashioneast

    Heidi’s bias always leads to the wrong person being chosen. Gretchen’s clothing were horrible from the beginning of the show to end. Heidi lacks good taste because she has no real fashion education or design expertise. This leads to her terrible fashion choices which she even selects for herself. Her need to always look as if she is still 20 years old is old and not complimentary. Michael should NEVER have been sent home. Gretchen can’t even tailor clothing! I wouldn’t purchase her stuff if it were selling for $5.00 at Walmart’s!

© 2013 Styleite, LLC | About Us | Advertise | Newsletter | Jobs | Privacy | User Agreement | Disclaimer | Terms of Service | Archives | Power Grid FAQ | Style Sheets FAQ | RSS RSS
Dan Abrams, Founder | Power Grid by Sound Strategies | Hosting by Datagram

X