Puck! Actually, he’s not necessarily her favorite, but she does think he’s the hottest. Which he is. We also think he’s sorely under-utilized. How fantastic was his rendition of “The Lady Is A Tramp”?
Then there was that sort of terrible music video Rachel Berry put together to give herself a “Bad Reputation.”
But our all-time favorite Puck performance might be his version of “Sweet Caroline”:
We love him.